I wouldn't mind having to write for a player a second time. I would imagine that focusing on the likes and dislikes makes it also easier for you to match people instead of trying to provide novel matches each year.

In this context, maybe it might be a good suggestion to provide novel prompts. I like recycling unused prompts myself, but it may be easier for the writer to receive a fresh set of prompts if they have written for this person before instead of being confronted with those again that have been dismissed the first time around.