brightknightie: Schanke reading Emily's novel (Reads)
Amy ([personal profile] brightknightie) wrote2024-01-03 07:41 am
Entry tags:

I love recommendations (I don't love WIPs)

I personally, as a fan reader, don't choose to read fanfic works in progress (WIPs). When I was new to fandom, in mailing-list days, I did try to follow some WIPs, but even those by established, respected, skilled authors, who had previously posted complete, well-crafted, novel-length stories, all eventually petered out, unfinished. I felt ill-done-by as a reader and decided not to engage with WIPs anymore. Even with professionally published series, I can sometimes be wary; I've seen planned trilogies never get their subsequent volumes, and if the first one wasn't written to be sufficiently complete unto itself, that can be frustrating. (And when I learned how George Eliot felt about publishing Romola serially, I felt even more justified. Serial releases are not for every author, not even when they're the custom.)

To be clear, truly complete stories posting a chapter per day, week, month -- those can be excellent! I love serial delivery! But how far can one trust that they are truly complete and edited... (obviously, I also won't read anything declaring itself unedited, eeeek; of course one can't always engage someone to help, but one can always strive to self-edit, and declaring proudly that one didn't bother drives me off).

On the other hand, what I do love to follow, as a fan reader, are recommendations. ♥ A strong, thoughtful recommendation for a well-crafted story, with interesting insights, canon-resonant characterizations, new ideas... chef's-kiss! Some folks post recommendations in their journals. Some make them via the AO3 bookmark feature. Some post them in recommendation communities like [community profile] fancake and [community profile] het_reccers. If you do any of those things, thank you! Thank you very much! If you know more recommendation communities for me to follow... recommend them? :-)


Post a comment in response:

(will be screened)
(will be screened if not validated)
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org