brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2025-01-10 08:24 am

HLH_Shortcuts '24 Recommendations

We had 20 new Highlander stories in [community profile] hlh_shortcuts this year. Find them all on the AO3.

Here are some that I, personally, subjectively, enjoyed most:

"Moondance or A Series of Extraordinary Events" by [archiveofourown.org profile] hafital
G, gen; ~19K words
Joyful. This story wraps a final sci-fi Gathering apocalypse -- starring Richie and Methos -- around many independent but threaded shorter missing-scene stories from throughout canon and beyond -- starring Richie and Angie, Richie and Tessa, Richie and May-Ling, Richie and etc. -- and not only delivers a happy ending at the last, but is again and again joyful and uplifting throughout. Each of the embedded stories would be lovely on its own. Yet they're strung like pearls on a necklace, progressing in a line, in a circle, in an orbit. It's more than its parts.

"Duo" by [archiveofourown.org profile] jasmasson
G, m/m; ~3K words
Amusing. A sensible outsider perspective delivers grins as it clashes with not-at-all sensible run-a-day HL canon in the persons of Duncan, Methos, and a hunter. The narrative packs satisfying, appropriately worded, canon references that fly over the head of the perspective character straight to the audience.

"Guests for the Weekend" by [archiveofourown.org profile] Annavere
G, gen; ~8K words
Unexpected. I was taken by surprise by how well this combination of characters -- Amanda, Anne, Richie -- came together in this off-to-the-side whodunnit romp of a mini-vacation for Anne, where the stakes are set by thieves so incompetent and security precautions so lacking that Amanda feels embarrassed and Richie plays the bait.

"Holy Ground" by [archiveofourown.org profile] merriman
G, gen; ~2K words
Historical. Have a Darius-lives scenario, with Methos and early Icelandic history. You're welcome. Bonus: Rumination on how the "Light Quickening" did and didn't do the work of reforming Darius, which he must have thought on often, and which I have opinions about.

Richie & Connor:

"In Good Company" by [archiveofourown.org profile] Teratornis
G, gen; ~6K words
Cathartic. Structured mostly as an action scene, a dojo workout, this piece has Richie process some of his many emotions in the wake of Tessa's death, his own immortality, and his encounter with Annie Devlin.

"Cousin's Retreat" by [archiveofourown.org profile] Sharpest_Asp
G, gen; ~1K words
Companionable. Richie gets to train with Connor for a while, as the audience gets to enjoy comparisons and contrasts between our two MacLeods, and the conviction that Richie is an adopted son of this clan.

Randi:

"The Pitch" by [archiveofourown.org profile] havocthecat
G, gen; ~2K words
Constructive. This piece worldbuilds around Randi across a decade, keeping her consistently canonical as it kneads and stretches her more realistic first-season world until it merges seamlessly with the more fantastic late-season canon, landing her as if fated in Joe's lap as he works to reform the Watchers.

"Behind the Story" by [archiveofourown.org profile] coralysendria
Unrated, gen, ~2K words
Transporting. Step into the heart of second season with the groundedness of first season. Tessa's murder is news; it's part of Randi's job. Tessa is also someone she knew; it's emotionally jarring, and emotion is not something Randi is particularly good at, so she gropes through the culturally prescribed motions until she finds her way to Richie, grieving, stunned, alone. We see Tessa through both of their eyes, Richie in that moment through Randi's eyes, and the world that was canon in those days as it must have been.

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2025-01-05 08:26 am

HLH_Shortcuts 2024 author reveals

Later, I'll share a proper [community profile] hlh_shortcuts '24 recs post! Right now, I just want to share the names of the two generous authors who wrote stories for my exchange match, and unveil which story I wrote, myself:

For me:
By me:
"Garbage and Flowers" for [archiveofourown.org profile] argentum_ls (T, gen, ~5K words) (Gregor, with Richie, Jennifer Hill, and memories of Alec Hill)

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-12-29 05:04 pm

A second HLH_Shortcuts '24 story for me!

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts has now released 18 of its 20 total 2024 stories. See the list. I expect that tomorrow, Monday, will bring the final releases, to be followed by the event’s traditional author-guessing game.

To my surprise, I’ve received a second story for my fest request this year: The Pitch” (G, gen, ~2K words). (For a completely spoiler-free reading experience, follow the link now and come back later for the rest of this post.) It stars Randi, supported by Joe, with cameos by Duncan and Methos.

Riding the wave of Randi’s conviction that Duncan could be the biggest story of her career, this piece sweeps from Randi spotting Joe near MacLeod & Noel Antiques, through a decade of dogging the literal and paperwork footsteps of Duncan and his friends, to Joe offering her the biggest story of her life... with one little catch.

This Randi is properly tenacious and perceptive. The story compellingly suggests how very much her interests, talents, and drive converge with the commitments and needs of the Watchers, to the point that it set me ruminating on the meta level where Randi and her local TV station may well have been a certain kind of unwitting structural first draft for Joe and the Watcher organization. (But why not both? ~grin~)

More comments on the story itself, of course! Take a look? Or, if this is not your personal HL flavor, try one of the others!

brightknightie: Richie parries prime as Duncan teaches him (Other Fandom HL Richie)
2024-12-27 09:15 am

Richie & Connor

Every [community profile] hlh_shortcuts, certain thought trends seem to emerge through the stories, particular themes or questions or canon moments that pop up independently in multiple unrelated, unalike stories that year.

This year, so far, "Richie & Connor after Tessa's death" seems to be a biggie. I have not yet read all the stories released to date, yet I believe I've already bumped into this concept four separate times, one way and another. (See the list of works.) I wonder whether there was a conversation about it somewhere that planted and nurtured these seeds, or whether the thought was carried on the wind long ago and only finally now the conditions for sprouting have arrived. As a trend, I'm certainly enjoying it!

Another trend this year, so far, seems to be very little Duncan. Few appearances, fewer as the perspective character. This is not as new or distinct. I suspect that, at this end of history, many folks find more unplucked story fruit with other characters.

brightknightie: Schanke reading Emily's novel (Reads)
2024-12-25 09:35 am

Preliminary Yuletide pickings

I won't start reading Yuletide until tomorrow, but I've opened tabs and wanted to share:

Yuletide brings us:
  • 2 new Forever Knight stories, one Nick/Natalie and one Nick/Lacroix. Take your pick.
  • 4 new works for assorted The Legend of Zelda games (the newest one and the least popular old ones were eligible). I am all agog to read the crossover between Majora's Mask and Columbo. See the list.
  • 1 new work for the Doctor Strange comics, this one starring Zelma Stanton, hero librarian! Check it out.
  • 0 new D&DC, BSG78, JttW, YB, Puss in Boots: The Last Wish or Dead Poets Society stories. But of course there are other fandoms to check over time, and treats to come.

Plus, HLH_Shortcuts continues to reveal 2 new Highlander stories per day. With 20 total works in this year's collection, we're at exactly 10 revealed and 10 to go, with a wide diversity of lengths, characters, and approaches ... though not a lot of Duncan, curiously, in those I've read so far. Find your favorite.


(A very merry Christmas to everyone celebrating! And warm wishes to everyone, period!)

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-12-23 09:06 am

HLH_Shortcuts is releasing! And the story for me is already available!

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts began releasing on the Winter Solstice, Duncan's Birthday, as is traditional, and will continue releasing a few stories per day until they're all shared. Many thanks to our new moderator team for all their efforts! Thanks to them, and to everyone who wrote and beta'd! Time to read:
The story written for my '24 fest match released on Sunday: "Behind the Story" (~2K words, gen). The anonymous creator chose not to use archive warnings and not to supply a rating; with no disrespect to those choices, I'd rate it "G" and No Archive Warnings Apply. If you're an HL fan, you're unlikely to find anything triggering here; this is what the show is about, I've always thought.

"Behind the Story" follows Randi McFarland in the days after Tessa's murder, how and where it touches her work and her conscience and her heart, culminating in a Randi & Richie scene I never knew I needed. There is so much Tessa here, through their eyes, and I love it. The story briskly opened long-shuttered second-season rooms in my imagination, and, in passing, dropped at least two bonus story ideas on the side.

I shared a longer comment on the story itself. You can read that for more on what in it caught my attention. Or ask! And of course there are many other stories to choose from, if this isn't your personal flavor of HL.

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-12-15 06:36 am
Entry tags:

HLH_Shortcuts deadline incoming...

December 15, 2024 at midnight Central Time is, I presume: today, Sunday, at 9:59pm/10:00pm Pacific Time.

([community profile] hlh_shortcuts loading due date) (Who, me, writing up to the last minute?)

UPDATE: It's Eastern Time, not Central Time. So 8:59pm/9:00pm Pacific Time. (I've uploaded a "bus pass." I just need to finish the real ending...)

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-10-18 08:47 am

HLH_Shortcuts '24 sign-ups close Saturday night

If you're planning to sign up for [community profile] hlh_shortcuts '24, be sure to get it in by 7:00pm Central Time tomorrow, Saturday, October 19. (That's 4:00pm Alaska Time, 5:00pm Pacific Time, 8:00pm Eastern Time, and 1:00am Sunday in the UK.)

Correction, 7:32pm: The AO3 sign-up page and Discord say midnight on October 20. Only the graphic banner on DW says 7pm on October 19; the DW information is mistaken.

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-10-13 12:20 pm

I'm signed up for HLH_Shortcuts '24 and I have prompts...

I've signed up for this year's [community profile] hlh_shortcuts exchange (see my sign-up) and filled-in my "Dear Author" letter placeholder post (see my letter). Sign-ups close on October 19. Stories come due December 15. Minimum 500 words. I count 14 sign-ups right now.

(BTW, the AO3 system hiccupped -- as it sometimes does -- and dropped Randi from the tag set after she was properly loaded there. If you'd like to read or write Randi this year, please just include her in your request and tags.)

In my letter, I ran fill-tilt jousting at -- totally optional! -- crossover/fusion concepts and regular story scenarios/prompts for possible inspiration. I thought that a few of you might find some of them amusing enough to be worth sharing separately from the context of the letter? Here are excerpts:

Possible crossover ideas )

Possible story prompts )

Open for chatting about any of these open-ended possible ideas as ideas (separate from whatever my match may choose to do or not do). :-)

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-10-10 07:49 am

HLH_Shortcuts "Dear Author" letter 2024

Dear [community profile] hlh_shortcuts author,

Thank you for sharing your Highlander love and creativity this year!

TLDR: My personal tip-top favorites are: gen; PG-13 and below; first through third seasons; Duncan, Tessa, Richie, Darius; Duncan/Tessa; good guys being good; the power of friendship; history, historical references, and flashbacks; grief and bereavement; fighting the good fight; and the struggles of the immortality fantasy as hyperbole/metaphor for real life struggles. I also enjoy other characters and story elements, so it's fine if none of those click for you.

Likes, dislikes, crossovers & prompts )

Again, thank you! Whatever you love best in HL, celebrate that, and I'm sure to enjoy it.

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2024-09-15 07:55 am

HLH_Shortcuts exchange is on this year (FYI a few changes)

TLDR: HLH_Shortcuts is on this year, coordinated by Killa and Havoc, with AO3-automated matching.

Details: For anyone fond of Highlander but not subscribed to [community profile] hlh_shortcuts -- the very long-running (back to LJ days) annual HL fic exchange -- here's a quick recap:

  • Tuesday 9/10: [personal profile] lferion, who last year took over the fest from original mod [personal profile] amand_r, regretfully announced that she couldn't run it again. She asked whether someone would like to take over or whether to end the fest. Read the post.

  • Wednesday 9/11: [personal profile] havocthecat invited anyone interested in modding or helping mod the fest -- and everyone interested in HL in general -- to join the "Le Blues Bar" HL Discord server. She posted a server invitation link. (If you already have a Discord account and want to join, just click it; if you don't have an account, you can set one up. If you already have an account and don't want to merge it with your HL fandom identity, you'll need a different phone number or email address to create a second Discord account. Or you can trust Discord's nicknames system. YMMV.) Read the post.

  • Unknown date: [personal profile] havocthecat created a Tumblr for the exchange. (I tried to find the creation date and the first post there to link to, but I'm slow, and Tumblr demanded that I sign up for an account before I could figure those out.) Visit the community.

  • Saturday 9/14: [personal profile] killabeez announced that [personal profile] lferion gave her and [personal profile] havocthecat access to the exchange's DW community and AO3 collection, that they'll work with other volunteers on Discord to ensure the fest continues, and to look for signups to open soon. Read the post.


I'm glad and grateful that folks are coming together to keep the annual HL exchange going! It's one of the three exchanges that have defined my personal fannish year for ages. I read it for years before I participated in it as a writer. It brings joy.

(I'm sorry that I don't feel able to make the platform leap needed to be really helpful with it where folks are right now. Perhaps in the future. There are many things to figure out about other platforms.)

brightknightie: Duncan with his sword against the Paris skyline (Other Fandom HL Duncan)
2024-01-09 07:50 am

"Promises and Promissory Notes" (HL) by me

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts de-anonymized over the weekend. Many correctly guessed me in the guessing game, which is fine; except for temporarily witholding full endnotes and not commenting on quite all the stories before reveals, I didn't at all try to hide! I hope that my easily identifiable writing habits are benign. (If not, hey, take me aside and gently help me improve them, please. Seriously.)

"Promises and Promissory Notes"
G, gen, ~6K words
Duncan & Amanda; with OCs, Joe, and Methos
Passing through Gilded Age San Francisco, Duncan runs into Amanda and tries very hard to avoid getting sucked into her latest shady scheme.


I've added the full endnotes. I'd like to thank [personal profile] dlyt and [personal profile] chelseagirl for brainstorming with me! And [personal profile] celli for encouraging me! And very much [personal profile] havocthecat for beta-reading, most specifically for identifying rough spots in my Amanda depiction and the balance of loose/tied plot threads!

A long-ish chat about writing the story )

brightknightie: Richie parries prime as Duncan teaches him (Other Fandom HL Richie)
2023-12-31 01:00 pm

HLH_Shortcuts '23 has finished releasing

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts brought us 25 new Highlander stories this year. Check them out via the community or directly in the AO3 collection. They're still anonymous, pending this fest's traditional author-guessing game.

The story gifted to me in the exchange is "Hellish Dreams of Heaven" (G, gen, ~4K words) (Richie, Duncan, Connor, Powell, Joe, Tessa). Entirely from Richie's perspective, it navigates sequentially through missing scenes fitting within -- or sparking off lines in -- "The Gathering," HL's premiere. I love the first few HL seasons best of all, as you know, and I like missing scenes and canon awareness, so this story is very comfortable in some ways. In others, though, it's rightly challenging; this early Richie's internal narrative bristles with disenchantment, between what he thinks he's found to be the ideal and the real. He wants to believe; he tells himself he's seen too much to believe... Yet he believes.

I haven't read all 25 stories, but of those I have, I'd especially like to recommend:
  • "Know Where It's At" (G, gen, ~5K words) (Richie, Darius, Methos, Tessa, Duncan) -- This time-travel fix-it pulls Richie from an unspecified future moment (possibly circa "Richard Redstone," possibly later) back into his younger body in the days leading up to Darius's murder by Horton. Can Richie put right what once went wrong?
  • "Friendship And Favors" (G, gen, ~2K words) (Rebecca, Darius) -- Of the two stories this year featuring Darius and Rebecca, this is the cooking one (the other is chess). This precisely-set historical interlude richly intertwines Darius and Rebecca in their shared hopes for the future: in individual students, in a community, and, implicitly, in the whole world exponentially in expanding rings. We readers know we'll lose them both too soon, but their work (and hope) will survive them.
  • "The Polyglot" (G, gen, ~3K words) (Methos, Richie, Joe, Amanda) -- This fun story lightly romps through some practical, ordinary, real-world threats, nothing a sword can solve, and delivers a happy ending all around.


brightknightie: Darius pours tea for Duncan. (Other Fandom HL Darius)
2023-12-23 08:48 am

HLH_Shortcuts '23 has begun releasing

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts, the annual Highlander fanfic exchange, has begun releasing. As usual, it starts at the winter solstice (Duncan's birthday) and continues as long as the stories last, unveiling several per day. You can follow the releases on their DW community or in this year's AO3 collection. Currently, 4 stories are live, 19 are in the collection, and a few pinch-hits or extensions are outstanding. (Naturally, HL is too big for Yuletide.)

While folks were waiting for the new stories, [personal profile] havocthecat posted links to all the past years of the exchange (2007-2022), including the LJ years in which folks emailed their stories to the mod for her to manually post anonymously on the community, and then manually edit in the names after reveals, because an important part of this event's tradition is the author guessing game, and there was not yet an AO3 ready to handle that kind of functionality directly in the happily better way that leaves the posted stories fully controlled by their authors. In addition, Havoc asked for recommendations from past years, and folks have recommended 13 stories so far! Read the recommendations.

I do have a story I've written in this year's collection. Many thanks to those who brainstormed and/or beta-read with me!

I look forward to reading the new stories...

brightknightie: Janette and Nick giving the red-wrapped firetruck to Daniel. (Gift)
2023-10-21 08:43 am

Key December exchanges sign-up countdowns

Highlander Holiday Shortcuts sign-ups remain open through 11:59pm Pacific Time, 22 October (which is about 38.5 hours away as I post this). I'll both write and read in this annual HL exchange. There are 13 sign-ups so far; here's mine. As always, reveals begin on Duncan's birthday, the winter solstice. See [community profile] hlh_shortcuts.

(If you end up as my match, and my sign-up doesn't quickly, happily click for you, please have the mod, or any of our common connections, nudge me to write an all-new Dear Author letter instead of merely linking to past ones! It's just that I have so many past ones. And I never run out of wanting more of what I love best? ~grin~)


Yuletide sign-ups remain open and editable through 9pm UTC, Saturday, 21 October (which is about 5.5 hours away as I post this). I'm not playing Yuletide; I do look for stories to read there every year, especially in D&DC and other very sleepy beloved fandoms. Indeed, many fandoms, I read only during Yuletide, skimming the lists, seeing what's there, and remembering fondly what I might not otherwise have thought of. See [community profile] yuletide_admin.

brightknightie: Darius pours tea for Duncan. (Other Fandom HL Darius)
2023-10-18 06:56 am

Sign-ups through this weekend for HLH_Shortcuts '23

In the unlikely event that anyone here doesn't yet know... [community profile] hlh_shortcuts, the annual Highlander fanfic exchange, is on! New mod, same fest. Minimum 500 words. All iterations of Highlander. Hand-matched from DW sign-ups. Posted on the AO3 (though I'm confident they'd allow DW posts for those who don't use the AO3). Anonymous releases over a week or so, followed by an author guessing game and reveals. Get the details and sign up.

Schedule:
  • Sign-ups: End October 22
  • Assignments sent: no later than November 2
  • Stories due: December 15
  • First story released: December 22

Come play with us...?

brightknightie: Duncan with his sword against the Paris skyline (Other Fandom HL Duncan)
2023-10-08 07:53 am

New "highlander-chat" DW community

About a month ago, per [personal profile] killabeez's survey and conversation on [community profile] hlh_shortcuts, requesting a new/revived central HL spot for general interaction, rather than exclusively fiction events, we created the new [community profile] highlander_chat community.

If it interests you, please join and please post when you have something to share.

We hope that this community can offer a handy place for Highlander fans to chat, squee, brainstorm, recommend, signal-boost, seek beta-readers and vid-betas and pinch-hitters, and just generally all the things that will help keep us connected with our HL fan friends (and make new ones). And of course we hope a new round of [community profile] hlh_shortcuts will come this year, and that the community could help folks connect around the game!

(I'll announce [community profile] highlander_chat on Fandom_on_DW and Fandom_Calendar in a few days, also name-dropping [community profile] hlh_shortcuts for anyone who doesn't know of it.) (Yep, I did submit an announcement to [community profile] hlh_shortcuts a few weeks ago, but the mods have either not seen it or chosen not to approve it, which is absolutely fine -- chatter doesn't belong on a fic community, by definition.)



brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2023-01-14 09:55 am

HLH_Shortcuts '22 recommendations

The 15 new stories in this year's [community profile] hlh_shortcuts will surely all be someone's favorites! For example, I must admit that, after a few paragraphs, I backed out and chose not to read Killa's no doubt outstanding "Pleased to Meet You" because it's a crossover with Lucifer, with which I'm personally not super comfortable. We all like different things!

Here are a few stories that appealed to me, myself:

"The Jaded Journalist" by Hafital
(G, gen, ~10K words) (Randi, Duncan, Tessa, Amanda, the De Valincourts, Methos)
I already recommended this while it was anonymous. Read my recommendation. This is the "What happened to Randi?" that I've been waiting for. It starts with a missing scene from "Band of Brothers" and then runs forward, always intertwining with canon yet never changing it, with the focus always on Randi and her career. Well-written, canon-rich, unique, perfectly voiced. Fantastic!

"A Credit To Her Teacher" by Malinaldarose
(G, gen, ~5K words) (Amanda, Michelle, Duncan, Joe)
I love "What happened with Michelle?" takes, and this one is the first I recall wholly from Amanda's perspective. It explores how taking on Michelle as a student connects to Amanda's memories of Rebecca and Kenny and ensures that Amanda succeeds -- that her canonical return with no on-screen mention of Michelle just means that Michelle is doing fine and Duncan knows all about it. Rebecca would be proud.

"To Be Useful" by Adabsolutely
(G, gen, ~3K words) (Methos, Duncan, Joe, Amanda, Amy)
The main appeal in this dialogue-heavy approach is the charming conversations in familiar voices. There's also a charming throughline of helping a very confused, homeless, new immortal, and other side-quests of helping various people in various ways. Lovely theming.

"Wintersong" by Black_Dwarf
(G, gen, ~2K words) (Amanda, Methos)
If Amanda is a favorite, maybe check this out. It's an on-point Amanda voice blending flippancy and insight. Methos takes time to miss who he was when he was with Alexa and Amanda pulls him back to the present.

"The Crane and the Pine" by Mackiedockie
(unrated, gen, 13K words) (Duncan, Methos, Amanda, Joe, Mai-Ling, Connor, others)
A pleasantly sprawling modern western fully of that comfortably familiar genre, with some action, some history, and a lot of connecting. It's a crossover with Longmire, but, not knowing that series, I still had no problem reading it as pure HL.

brightknightie: Richie parries prime as Duncan teaches him (Other Fandom HL Richie)
2023-01-14 08:47 am

What I wrote for HLH_Shortcuts '22

[community profile] hlh_shortcuts has de-anonymized! Find all 15 stories with their authors on the AO3.

Now that the guessing game is complete, I can share which new Highlander story I wrote:
"Would you leave" (G, gen, ~3K words).
Richie, Angie, Anne, Duncan. Richie and Anne talk after Mac flees an argument he can't win; Angie learns of the crash at the motorcycle track.

Essentially, it's a missing scene from "Testimony," introduced by a missing scene from "Take Back the Night," with a referenced missing scene from "The Darkness," landing on what I intend as a turn into canon divergence, from which Richie and Angie will get to step out of canon's camera frame and build a better fate for themselves, together, whether as friends or lovers — either way, as partners. Its inspiration spark was very much in a "here, have some prompts" post on my recipient's journal (thank you, [personal profile] argentum_ls!).

Apparently, the story has "Brightknightie" written all over it, even without endnotes, because 6 players guessed me as its author, and no one guessed me as the author of anything else. Um. Well, let's see: rigorous canonicity, mortal characters, surviving loss... the same 3-part missing-scene-and-a-twist structure I wrote last year... compulsive "end" written at the end... yep, sounds like me.

I will now go put on its endnotes (thank you for beta-reading, [personal profile] skieswideopen!). Then I'll return with recommendations for the rest of the exchange. Lots of great stories!

brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
2023-01-06 07:55 pm
Entry tags:

a possible side-effect of the HLH_Shortcuts author-guessing game

I love the annual [community profile] hlh_shortcuts exchange, which brings us fresh new HL stories every winter. Read this year's works. I've been reading in the event for many more years than I've been writing in it.

I worry, though, that its author guessing game can sometimes discourage newer players who couldn't possibly guess its effects, and might feel hurt while relatively few comments and kudos come in through the posting period and guessing game. Newer players might interpret this as their stories being rejected by their fellow players. I hope and believe that's usually not what happens.

Here's what I think I understand about what happens in this exchange, which makes it different from most events:

Back before the A03, the writers emailed their stories to the moderator, who then posted them herself, one by one, on the HLH_Shortcuts LiveJournal community, anonymously. People read the stories and commented (and you could comment on your own story there). At the end of posting, the community made a game of guessing who wrote each story. Then the moderator edited each LJ post to add the author's name and announced the winner of the guessing game.

When the AO3 came along, and then DW, the exchange moved. When you post your own story on the AO3, you can't comment on it or kudo it [per comments below, we can comment on our own AO3 stories! I never knew]. So if you choose to comment or kudo on all the stories except the one you wrote, you've revealed which story you wrote, by process of elimination. So folks who want to play (or just support) the guessing game will deliberately not comment on all the stories -- indeed, they may particularly choose not to comment on stories that they hope others will think they wrote!

This should all come around to a happy ending with folks coming back to comment and kudos on more of the stories after reveals. Often they do! Sometimes, though, this approach can seem to encourage less total interaction than an otherwise similar event might earn during an equivalent play period. No momentum.

Anyway, that's just what I think, myself. Many of you may know more; I could be misguided. I just would like everyone to know, in this exchange, silence may actually mean folks hope to be mistaken for you!