brightknightie: Duncan and Tessa embrace on the sidewalk. (Other Fandom Highlander)
Dear HLH_Shortcuts Author:

Thank you for sharing your love of HL! I’m sure that whatever you most want to celebrate in any of the requested characters will make a lovely story!

What I love in HL )
What I like in fanfic generally )
Some possible HL story scenarios/prompts )

Thank you very much! See you come Duncan’s birthday. :-D

brightknightie: Urs and Nick in the Raven (Nick/Urs was dubbed "Les Miserables.") (Les Mis)
Dear RetroTVExchange Author:

Hi! Thank you for sharing these marvelous retro fandoms! I’m sure that whatever you most want to celebrate in these characters and their worlds will make a lovely story! If you’d like more story thoughts from me, read on.

Some feelings across fandoms

I often love best stories with the feel of canon, whether as a scene, episode, or prequel/sequel that could have been added seamlessly, or as a different choice or chance that would have branched and led on from canon to something new.

With a few dear exceptions, I usually prefer gen to romance. Mystery, drama, history, reflection, confrontation, growth, discovery, tragedy! (I opt in for tragedy including requested character death, as long as the loss is shown to be meaningful to the survivors; I often like stories of continuing on from grief.) And, of course, the quiet times between adventures! For romance, I have fairly vanilla tastes. Whether m/f or f/f or m/m as best suits the characters, I especially value fidelity, mutuality, and complementarity, where the parties each bring strengths and weaknesses to the relationship such as to grow stronger together than apart. (I prefer no polyamory for these characters, please.)

Where applicable — not every character fits! — I especially love protagonists who incidentally, without thinking they’re doing something special, show that they value others highly — that is, not only their own loved ones, but the dignity and abundant life of all people, especially those on the margins.

Please do feel free to mix and match the requested characters with other appropriate characters to build your story as you need. Where I’ve requested “[Character] & none,” you need not literally limit the story to only the one requested character inside her or his own head; just please give the requested character the lead and focus.

On dislikes: Villains can be redeemed — and, in tragedies, can win — but I don’t enjoy stories that defend or celebrate evil. (FK note: I understand vampirism as an evil.) I’m happy to follow two competing ideals pitted against each other, and to cry over a good that is lost, but please don't ask me to root for cruelty, selfishness, domination, or other evils.

Some fandom & character-specific feelings

D&DC: Dungeons & Dragons (the ‘80s cartoon) )
HL: Highlander: The Series )
BSG78: Battlestar Galactica (the original) )
FK: Forever Knight )


Do Not Want (DNW)

Do Not Want (DNW) )

If that isn’t far more than enough ;-) I have a standing likes and dislikes post. Check it out.

Thank you very much!

brightknightie: With Hank and Diana in the lead, the children confront Tiamat. (Other Fandom D&D poster)
Dear Everywoman Author:

Hi! Thank you for also being interested in these dear fandoms, and their wonderful women characters. I’m sure that whatever you most want to celebrate in these characters will make a lovely story! If you’d like more story thoughts from me, read on.

Some feelings across fandoms

I often love best stories with the feel of canon, whether as a scene or episode that could have been added seamlessly, or as a different choice or chance that would have branched and led somewhere wholly unlike where canon went, yet rooted in that original reality.

With a few exceptions, I usually prefer gen to romance. Mystery, drama, history, reflection, confrontation, growth, discovery, tragedy! (I opt in for tragedy including character death, as long as the loss is shown as meaningful to the survivors; I generally like stories of grief and continuing on.) And, of course, the quiet times between adventures! For romance, I have fairly vanilla tastes. Whether m/f or f/f in this exchange, I especially value fidelity, mutuality, and complementarity, where the parties each bring strengths and weaknesses to the relationship such as to grow stronger together than apart.

Where applicable, I especially love protagonists who incidentally, without thinking they’re doing something special, show that they value others highly — that is, not only their own loved ones, but the dignity and abundant life of all people, especially those on the margins.

Please do mix and match the requested characters with other appropriate characters to build your story!

On dislikes: Villains can be redeemed — and, in tragedies, can win! — but I don’t enjoy stories that defend or celebrate evil. (FK note: I understand vampirism as an evil.) I’m happy to follow two competing ideals pitted against each other, and to cry over a good that is lost; I don’t like to be asked to root for that which is wrong.

Some fandom & character-specific feelings

D&DC: Dungeons & Dragons (the ‘80s cartoon) )
HL: Highlander: The Series )
BSG78: Battlestar Galactica (the original) )
YB: Young Blades )
FK: Forever Knight )
The Equalizer (TV 2021) )

Do Not Want (DNW)

Do Not Want (DNW) )

If that isn’t far more than enough ;-) I have a standing likes and dislikes post. Check it out.

Thank you very much!

brightknightie: Nick on his couch, smiling. (Nick Amused)
I update my standing fanfic likes and dislikes "letter" before every ficathon in which I participate. Have I ever mentioned that?

Well, anyway, if someone were looking for that formidably lengthy catalogue, I last updated it June 7, 2015. ;-)
brightknightie: Magda thanking Nick in the precinct (Thanks)
No one is presently writing me a story in any exchange fest, so I thought this might be a good time to get around to one of those standing "Fanfic Likes and Dislikes" posts, more comprehensive than an individual fest sign-up. (I'll link to it from my profile.)

— Updated January 18, 2021 —


Preface: If you're creating for me in an exchange-style ficathon or other fannish event — thank you! — and you're seeking more details about what I embrace and avoid as a fanfiction reader, here's... way too much information. Really. Please don't let this be a straitjacket or a formula. Back away if necessary. Laugh it off and forge ahead! Wherever you find your passion for the canon and characters in our shared fandom is the right place to build your story, and I'm sure to enjoy it there. You've been warned... )

Profile

brightknightie: At dawn, a white knight raises her lance (Default)
Amy

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags

Tags

Style Credit

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios
Page generated Tuesday, July 8th, 2025 06:04 am